Thursday, October 16, 2014

Was Napoleon's impact a good one or nah?

Many people looked at Napoleon as an influential figure. In a document called The Lost Voices of 
Napoleonic Historians, a historian describes Napoleon as a great ruler, "He was the greatest genius of his time," she wrote, adding, "perhaps of all time, yet he lacked the crown of greatness -- that high wisdom born of reflection and introspection which knows its own powers and limitations, and never abuses them; that fine sense of proportion which holds the rights of others in the same solemn reverence which it demands for its own."


Napoleon Bonaparte had an influential impact on France as well as the rest of Europe. With his superior rule he was able to change the country politically, socially and economically. Napoleon’s biggest impact occurred through military and political innovations. Changes in this area are because he had control over countries such as Belgium, Egypt, France, Rhineland, Holland and many other countries. With his power, he had the authority to change how countries were run. A major change was the introduction of a new government system called meritocracy, a way of ruling that appointed a leader based on their ability to lead and their knowledge instead of their social class and their past kinns. This system complies with the change in the social economy that Napoleon imposed because it exploited nobility and brought focus to the common man.

Napoleon positively impacted social systems by making all treated and valued equally. To achieve that, he extradited serfdom and got rid of nobility power which ensured the common people of France an improved life. The majority of the people in France supported this new system, except for the high class nobles. The high class nobles were upset with this new system because their power decreased. Madame de Stael was a nobility member and a daughter of King Louis XVI’s former financial adviser. In a document I read she describes her opinion on the new social system. She says, "His system was to encroach daily upon France's liberty and Europe's independce." She disagrees with Napoleon’s system because she loses her power. On the other hand, a man named Michel Marshall Rey benefits from the new system because he was an officer who served for Napoleon. Rey describes Napoleon as an "immoral legend." He benefited from Napoleon's ruling because he gained power and had the ear of France. Napoleon gained both military and political power through appealing to the masses of people.


Napoleon also made enormous economic improvements. He expanded trade throughout the many countries he conquered. He also built many new canals and roads. This benefited the people because it allowed for a faster flow of trade throughout the countries, creating more revenue. Another way he stimulated and enhanced the economic system was through tariffs outside of Europe where he was able to get products for better trade. Along with trade he was able to balance France’s budget.  All of these accomplishments increased revenue for France. 


The Lost Voices of  Napoleonic Historians
http://www.napoleon-series.org/research/biographies/c_historians.html

http://www.mrodenberg.com/category/corsica/

Document sources: Ten Years of exile by Madame de Stael and The French Revolution and Napoleon:An eye witness history by Joe H. Kringberger


No comments:

Post a Comment